By 2009, Taking Back Sunday had already conquered Warped Tour, so they aimed for the arenas on their fourth album, recruiting Paul McCartney producer David Kahne for a set of polished pop-rock that never skimps on the angsty guitars or the shout-along vocals. The title track and "Sink Into Me" soar like prime Foo Fighters, with choruses large enough to hook even the casual emo fan, while "Where My Mouth Is" is a shimmering, modern power ballad in the mold of Coldplay.