259 episodes

Scott McNulty discusses a randomly selected episode of “Star Trek” — all series, all seasons — with a non-random guest.

Random Trek The Incomparable

    • TV & Film
    • 4.6 • 147 Ratings

Scott McNulty discusses a randomly selected episode of “Star Trek” — all series, all seasons — with a non-random guest.

    "Things Past" (DS9) with David J. Loehr

    "Things Past" (DS9) with David J. Loehr

    David J Loehr, writer and podcaster, joins Scott to discuss “Things Past” (DS9 S5E8). Topics include the lack of Neelix, Odo’s tortured soul, and the creepy uncanny vibe that allows for effective, and cheap, Star Trek episodes. Next on Random Trek: “Genesis” (TNG S7E19) with James Thomson....

    • 46 min
    "Daedalus" (ENT) with John Siracusa

    "Daedalus" (ENT) with John Siracusa

    John Siracusa, developer, writer, and podcaster, joins Scott to discuss “Daedalus” (ENT S4E10). Topics include being a professional podcaster, the emotions of Vulcans, and Captain Archer’s judgment (or lack thereof). Next on Random Trek: “Things Past” (DS9 S5E8) with David J Loehr....

    • 46 min
    "The Siege of AR-558" (DS9) with Grant Jun Otsuki

    "The Siege of AR-558" (DS9) with Grant Jun Otsuki

    Grant Jun Otsuki, a cultural anthropologist, joins Scott to discuss "The Siege of AR-558" (DS9 S7E8). We attempt to have a lighthearted conversation about a very heavy episode of Deep Space Nine. Topics include which Captain you'd want to work for, how great Avery Brooks' performance is in this episode, and why the heck was Quark allowed to hang around in this situation. Be sure to read Grant's fantastic McSweeney's piece "Due to Falling Enrollments, We Will No Longer Offer Courses In Romulan At Starfleet Academy." Next Episode: "Daedalus" (ENT S4E10) with John Siracusa....

    • 50 min
    "Day of the Dove" (TOS) with Jason Snell

    "Day of the Dove" (TOS) with Jason Snell

    Jason Snell, Random Trek’s most frequent guest, joins Scott to discuss “Day of the Dove” (TOS S3E11). Topics include our favorite Klingons, whatever the deal is with these energy aliens, and the “hidden” message of this episode. Watch “Day of the Dove” for yourself: Amazon Instant Video Paramount+ Blu-Rays...

    • 45 min
    "Wrongs Darker Than Death or Night" (DS9) with Claire L. Evans

    "Wrongs Darker Than Death or Night" (DS9) with Claire L. Evans

    Claire L. Evans, writer and musician, joins Scott to discuss “Wrongs Darker Than Death or Night” (DS9 S6E17). Topics include how great Dax is, war crimes, and the ease of time travel when you’re a Bajoran. Just a warning -given the content of this episode, we talk about some mature topics. On a lighter note, read Claire’s history of the corporate presentation. Watch Wrongs Darker Than Death or Night for yourself: Amazon Instant Video Paramount Plus DVDs...

    • 45 min
    "The Voyager Conspiracy" (VOY) with Erika Ensign

    "The Voyager Conspiracy" (VOY) with Erika Ensign

    Erika Ensign, podcaster and trivia enthusiast, joins Scott to discuss “The Voyager Conspiracy” (S6E9). Topics include conspiracy theories, the many possible loves of Capt. Janeway, and the complete lack of Reginald Barclay in this episode. Watch “The Voyager Conspiracy” for yourself: Amazon Instant Video Paramount Plus DVDs...

    • 42 min

Customer Reviews

4.6 out of 5
147 Ratings

147 Ratings

Caitlee M. ,

Still My Favorite Sleep Podcast

I decided I should go ahead and upgrade my original review to five stars.

I say this was absolutely every intention of a compliment: This podcast is perfect for helping me sleep. Whether I’ve hurt my back and need to focus on something other than pain, or I’m just full of anxiety about work, this podcast has been a stalwart companion helping me get through the night. I’m serious when I say that I’m on at least my seventh listen through of the entire playlist, and there’s only about two episodes I’ve heard the entirety of.

There is something incredibly soothing about the host’s voice. And he reads his sponsor ads at the same volume in the same voice, unlike other “official” sleep-aid podcasts I’ve tried. I find it very comforting to fall asleep to him asking various cohosts about how they feel about Neelix, and then wake up just long enough to hear everyone complain about Archer or gushing about Janeway. I learn things about bananas, then I’m asleep again. There are no episode clips or jingles, just soft discussions about Star Trek.

My only complaints are that sometimes the sound isn’t balanced super well. If I want to hear both hosts, in one episode one might be significantly louder than the other. And the red-alert bleep for the swearing can be jarring, especially if the guest host is prone to swearing frequently. But hey, this isn’t a podcast specifically designed for helping the listener sleep, so I can’t exactly fault anybody for those issues.

In conclusion, I know it’s probably not the thing most people making a podcast want to hear, that they are great for sleeping to. But from the bottom of my heart, thank you. I love Random Trek. I’m so glad it’s back to naming the occasional episode!

GhighiAnn ,

Makes my day

Love the format, the guests, and especially the host. Thank you.

gffghgben ,

Scott why do you HATE Enterprise

Though every other episodes are pretty good

Top Podcasts In TV & Film

Just B Divorced with Bethenny Frankel
iHeartPodcasts
Who Killed the Video Star: The Story of MTV
Audacy Studios
Watch What Crappens
Ben Mandelker & Ronnie Karam | Wondery
Give Them Lala
Lala Kent | Cumulus Podcast Network
FX’s Shōgun: The Official Podcast
FX
Not Skinny But Not Fat
Dear Media, Amanda Hirsch

More by The Incomparable

The Incomparable Mothership
Jason Snell
NASA Vending Machine (watching "For All Mankind")
Dan Moren and Jason Snell
Vulcan Hello (Star Trek Discovery, Picard, Strange New Worlds)
Scott McNulty and Jason Snell
Somehow I Manage (Rewatching "The Office")
Tiff Arment and Stephen Hackett
A Complicated Profession: "Star Wars" on TV
Dan Moren
Robot or Not?
John Siracusa and Jason Snell